Pages

Subscribe:

Thursday, 9 February 2012

Thinking, Fast and Slow [Hardcover]

Thinking, Fast and Slow [Hardcover]


"He's in a zone. He can't miss." Paul Pierce has just made his sixth three-pointer in seven attempts in the second half. "I told you, he's a streak shooter. When he's hot, he's hot." The Celtics-Lakers game is on the big screen at the neighborhood sports bar. The evidence is there for all to see. Who can argue? Now imagine that conversation is taking place between the fast thinking part of your brain, known as "System 1" in this remarkable book, and "System 2", the slow thinking, anchor-to-windward part of your brain. "It just looks that way," System 2 will say. As Kahneman demonstrates, "there is no such thing as a hot hand in professional basketball." His proof: "the sequence of successes and missed shots satisfies all the tests of randomness. The hot hand is entirely in the eye of the beholders, who are consistently too quick to perceive order and causality in randomness. The hot hand is a massive and widespread cognitive illusion."

Man does not live by cognitive illusion alone, although you might think so when reading "Thinking Fast and Slow." Every now and then, particularly when something important is on the line, a mortgage rate, the selection of a new CEO or surgeon to repair your colon, our System 2 brain makes (or very well ought to make) an appearance. If it does its job, it will drag the analysis back to the base line for the traits or qualities or outcomes we seek and start from there. Better outcomes should result and often do.

My mind works just like yours. It's a soft touch for the easy answer, the rule of thumb that pops into mind as I decide how many bottles of wine to buy for an open house (I nearly always buy more than I need), or whether to sign up in September to purchase our winter supply of heating fuel at a fixed rate to protect against upswings in the price. How do I decide? Chances are that I will think back to last winter, recall how unusually cold it was, decide that this winter is likely to be warmer so I'll gamble on the floating rate. This is a good example of the way we trust out ability to make a decision based on a single factor (here, last year's recalled temperatures), reach a conclusion that makes us feel real smart, and then wring our hands when it turns out that the cost of fuel for the winter depended not on the average temperature but on the average price that the Chinese were willing to pay in an era of expanding demand and diminishing supply. Our decision, as so often happens, was critically affected by a factor or factors that we failed to consider. We weren't able to find our way back to the base line, back to System 2.

I have lived through a great many winters in cold climates (this is my 78th).In the week or so it took me to read this book, I learned more about the way my mind (and yours) works than I have in my entire life and that includes my legal training and law practice. I can't begin to count the mistakes I've made by letting my System 1 mind do most of my day to day planning and decision-making. Not any more. I have Daniel Kahneman to thank for that. And I have done so, in part, by buying copies of his book for my children and asking them to read it as their birthday present to me this year. Among his other talents, Kahneman's pedagogy is graceful, erudite and eminently suited to his subject.

End note. Here is one my favorite bits of learning in "Thinking Fast". Quoting work done by Robyn Dawes, Kahneman notes that "[s]imple equally weighted formulas based on existing statistics or common sense are very often good predictors of significant outcomes. In a memorable example Dawes showed that marital stability is well predicted by a formula: `frequency of lovemaking minus frequency of quarrels'." Kahneman adds, as I'm sure that you could have told me,"[y]ou don't want the result to be a negative number."



*** Terms and Disclaimer *** CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED ‘AS IS’ AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
Interested This: